Imagine you’re interviewing two real estate agents to sell your home in Ocoee. One sits at your kitchen table and says, “I sold 800 homes last year.” The other says, “I sold 56.” Before you give the first agent the listing, I’d ask both of them one question. How many of those buyers or sellers did you personally represent?
The agent with 56 sales might be able to tell you why the house around the corner needed a price adjustment and what finally got the buyer to sign. The agent advertising 800 might have to call someone else to find out. I know which conversation I’d rather have at my kitchen table.
What does “800 homes sold” actually mean?
Eight hundred closings in a year works out to a little more than two a day, every day, including weekends, Thanksgiving and Christmas. Spread those same 800 closings across 100 agents and you get an average of eight per agent. That’s a perfectly believable brokerage total. The word that bothers me is I.
It reminds me of the old McDonald’s signs that said “billions served.” Imagine the guy who runs one McDonald’s in Ocoee pointing to that sign and telling you he personally sold every one of those hamburgers. You’d laugh. You know it took a whole lot of people in a whole lot of restaurants to sell that many burgers. Put one agent’s face next to “800 homes sold,” though, and somehow we forget to ask the same question.
A broker can pay for a lead, pass it to an agent and build a good business that way. But suppose that agent walked the house with the seller, answered the Sunday phone calls, negotiated the inspection repairs and saw the sale through closing. If the broker never met the seller or set foot in the house, I think it’s misleading for the broker to tell the next seller, “I sold that home.” “My team sold it” is just as easy to say, and it gives the agent who did the work some credit.
How I counted sales when I owned a brokerage
I ran CENTURY 21 Professional Group in Ocoee for 12 years. When an agent in my office handled a sale from start to finish, that agent got the credit. When another agent and I genuinely shared a deal, I took 50% credit. I was proud of what the office produced, and I could talk about that without adding somebody else’s closing to my personal track record.
This matters to agents, too. If you’re building a career on a real estate team, ask to see how a recent closing appears under your name. Here in Central Florida, Stellar MLS allows production reports to be grouped by agent, team or office. If you eventually go out on your own, you’ll want to know what your individual report shows when a prospective client asks about your experience. Stellar MLS guide to production reports
What to ask before hiring a real estate agent
If you’re choosing a listing agent in Winter Garden or a buyer’s agent in Ocoee, start with a sale that has something in common with yours. Here are the questions I’d ask across that kitchen table.
- “Can you walk me through a recent sale you personally handled in my neighborhood or price range?” Ask what came up and what the agent did about it. You’ll learn more from that story than from a leaderboard.
- “How many buyers and sellers are you working with right now?” Fifty or sixty closings last year tells you the agent has experience. Their workload today tells you more about whether they’ll have time for you.
- “If we get a repair request at four o’clock on Friday, who’s calling me?” A name is a good answer. If another agent will handle that conversation, I’d want to meet them before signing.
So how much is too much? For me, it’s the point where the person asking for your business is too busy to do the work you’re hiring them for. That can happen at 50 sales. A team can close 800 and take excellent care of you. Tell me who did the work, tell me who’s going to take care of me, and let me decide. I can appreciate the hustle. I just want the credit to go to the people doing it.
If you’re buying or selling a home in Central Florida, ask me those same questions. Call or text me at 407-948-8295. When an offer comes in and you want to talk it through, you’ll know whose number to dial.
When you hire David Dorman you GET David Dorman.